Skip to content
Real Estate Intelligence
INA NETWORK

Pet-Friendly Policy Success Stories vs. Regrets: What Makes the Difference for Landlords

A candid comparison of landlords who successfully filled vacancies by allowing pets versus those who came to regret the decision, with insights on what separates the two outcomes.

Last updated: About 2 min read

For rental property owners, allowing pets is a strategy that can dramatically improve vacancy rates—but there are also many owners who regret it. This article explains what differentiates successful landlords who implemented pet-friendly policies from those who regret it, and provides practical guidance on pet-friendly rental management.

Why Pet-Friendly Properties Are Attracting Attention

Japan's pet ownership rate has been rising year by year, and many pet owners struggle to find suitable rental housing. As a result, pet-friendly properties command a rental premium compared to similar properties and have higher occupancy rates. In particular, single workers and couples with pets have strong preferences for their place of residence, and long tenancy periods can also be expected.

Success Stories: Owners Who Filled Vacancies by Going Pet-Friendly

Studio Unit Owner (Tokyo, Building Age: 20 Years)

A studio unit that had been vacant for three months went fully occupied within the month after switching to pet-friendly. Rent was raised by 5,000 yen per month, more than offsetting the cleanup costs at move-out. The key was setting clear pet-related rules in the lease agreement from the outset.

Apartment Owner (Saitama, 6 Units)

From a starting point of a 50% occupancy rate, going pet-friendly across three units reduced vacancies. Pet deposits and pet rent were set to ensure move-out cleanup costs could be covered. Regular building inspections were added to prevent disputes between tenants.

Regret Stories: Owners Who Struggled After Going Pet-Friendly

Building Damage Was Worse Than Expected

Scratches on flooring and doors, pet odors embedded in walls and ceilings—damage at move-out was significantly more severe than for regular tenants. The cost of cleanup far exceeded the pet deposit, resulting in a net loss.

Disputes Between Tenants

In a building where some units were pet-friendly and others were not, noise and odor complaints from non-pet units arose. Setting up areas of the building properly and communicating clearly with existing tenants in advance are essential.

Key Points for Successfully Going Pet-Friendly

1. Set Sufficient Pet Deposits and Pet Rent

Pet deposits and pet rent of one to two months' rent equivalent can cover the increased move-out cleanup costs. Setting fees that reflect the actual cost is essential.

2. Specify Rules in the Lease Agreement

Clearly specify items such as permitted pet species and number, noise prevention measures, and restoration obligations at move-out. Clear rules from the beginning prevent disputes later.

3. Regularly Inspect the Property

Regular inspections every six to twelve months allow early detection of damage and serve as an opportunity to check compliance with pet-related rules.

4. Consult with Neighboring Tenants

If converting some units of a building to pet-friendly, explain the situation to existing tenants in advance and confirm there are no objections. Providing soundproofing measures as needed helps maintain harmonious relations.

Costs and Return on Investment When Going Pet-Friendly

ItemCost EstimateNotes
Pet deposit1–2 months' rentCovers cleanup and restoration costs at move-out
Pet rent (monthly)3,000–10,000 yenOngoing income to offset wear and building maintenance
Restoration costs at move-out50,000–300,000 yenVaries by property type and period of occupancy
Improvement in occupancy rate10–30% improvement possibleVaries by area and property type

Related Reading

  • Top Reasons Tenants Move Out and How to Prevent Them
  • Three Differentiation Strategies to Maximize Rental Revenue

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q. Which types of pets should be allowed and which should be restricted?

Small cats and dogs are most common. Large dogs and exotic pets (reptiles, birds, etc.) carry higher risks of building damage and disputes, so it is safer to restrict them. Specify clearly in the contract.

Q. Is it possible to go pet-friendly only for specific units?

Possible, but explain to existing non-pet tenants in advance and design the building layout to minimize impacts such as noise and odors. Setting up pet-friendly units on specific floors or in specific sections is one approach.

Q. What is the appropriate amount for a pet deposit?

One to two months' rent equivalent is a general guideline. Calculate based on anticipated move-out restoration costs and set an amount that fully covers the extra costs compared to regular tenants.

Daisuke Inazawa, President & CEO of INA&Associates Inc.

Author

President & CEOINA&Associates Inc.

President & CEO of INA&Associates Inc. Leads real estate brokerage, rental leasing, and property management across Greater Tokyo and the Kansai region. Specialises in income-property investment strategy and advisory for ultra-high-net-worth individuals.

Daisuke Inazawa is the President and CEO of INA&Associates Inc., a Japanese real estate firm headquartered in Osaka with a Tokyo branch. He leads the company's three core businesses — real estate sales brokerage, rental leasing, and property management — across the Greater Tokyo Area and the Kansai region.

His areas of expertise include investment strategy for income-generating real estate, profitability optimisation of rental operations, real estate advisory for ultra-high-net-worth individuals (UHNWIs) and institutional investors, and cross-border real estate investment. He provides data-driven, long-horizon advisory to investors in Japan and overseas.

Under the management philosophy "a company's most important asset is its people," he positions INA&Associates as a "people-investment company" and is committed to sustainable corporate-value creation through talent development. He also writes and speaks publicly on leadership and organisational culture in times of change.

He has passed eleven Japanese professional qualification examinations: Licensed Real Estate Broker (Takken), Certified Real Estate Consulting Master, Licensed Condominium Manager, Licensed Building Management Supervisor, Certified Rental Housing Management Professional, Gyōseishoshi Lawyer (administrative scrivener), Certified Personal Information Protection Officer, Class-A Fire Prevention Manager, Certified Auctioned Real Estate Specialist, Certified Condominium Maintenance Engineer, and Licensed Moneylending Operations Supervisor.

  • Licensed Real Estate Broker (Takken)
  • Certified Real Estate Consulting Master
  • Licensed Condominium Manager
  • Licensed Building Management Supervisor
  • Certified Rental Housing Management Professional
  • Gyōseishoshi Lawyer (Administrative Scrivener)
  • Certified Personal Information Protection Officer
  • Class-A Fire Prevention Manager
  • Certified Auctioned Real Estate Specialist
  • Certified Condominium Maintenance Engineer
  • Licensed Moneylending Operations Supervisor