Skip to content
Real Estate Intelligence
COLUMN

Apartment Buyback vs Brokerage: Key Differences and How to Choose

A thorough comparison of apartment buyback and brokerage, explaining how to choose the right selling method based on price, speed, and fees. It also outlines the types of properties best suited to buyback.

Last updated: About 1 min read

When selling a condominium, there are two main options: a direct purchase and brokerage. Because these methods differ significantly in price, speed, and fees, choosing the right one for your situation is important. In this article, we explain the differences between direct purchase and brokerage, as well as the characteristics of condominiums that are well suited to direct purchase.

What is the difference between condominium purchase and brokerage?

Before choosing a selling method, it is important to understand how each option works.

What is direct purchase?

It is a method in which a real estate company buys the property directly. Because the business model is based on reselling after renovation, the sale price is lower than with brokerage. However, cash conversion is faster and no brokerage fee is required.

What is brokerage?

It is a method in which a real estate company finds a buyer for you. You may be able to sell at a price close to market value, but the sale takes longer and brokerage fees will also apply.

Comparison ItemDirect PurchaseBrokerage
Sale Price60% to 80% of market valueClose to market value
Time to Sell1 to 2 weeks3 to 6 months
Brokerage FeeNone3% of the sale price + 60,000 yen
Property ViewingsNot requiredRequired

These condominiums are well suited to direct purchase

Let’s look at specific situations where choosing direct purchase makes sense.

Properties that require renovation

Properties with poor interior condition can create a negative impression in brokerage sales, but with direct purchase, poor condition is not a problem because the property will be resold after renovation. In some cases, you may retain more money through direct purchase than by renovating the property yourself and selling it through brokerage.

When you want to sell in a short period

If you want to complete the sale within one to two months due to a sudden job transfer or similar circumstances, direct purchase is the best option. If you have a clear deadline, a sale with a purchase guarantee is also an option.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q. Which leaves more money in hand, direct purchase or brokerage?

In general, brokerage can achieve a higher sale price, but after subtracting renovation costs and brokerage fees, there are cases where direct purchase is more advantageous.

Q. How is the appraisal amount determined in a direct purchase?

It is calculated backward from the expected profit after resale. It is important to request appraisals from multiple direct buyers and compare them.

Q. What is a purchase guarantee?

It is a system in which the property is first listed through brokerage for a certain period, and if it does not sell, the transaction switches to direct purchase. It is a method that balances price and speed.

Daisuke Inazawa, President & CEO of INA&Associates Inc.

Author

President & CEOINA&Associates Inc.

President & CEO of INA&Associates Inc. Leads real estate brokerage, rental leasing, and property management across Greater Tokyo and the Kansai region. Specialises in income-property investment strategy and advisory for ultra-high-net-worth individuals.

Daisuke Inazawa is the President and CEO of INA&Associates Inc., a Japanese real estate firm headquartered in Osaka with a Tokyo branch. He leads the company's three core businesses — real estate sales brokerage, rental leasing, and property management — across the Greater Tokyo Area and the Kansai region.

His areas of expertise include investment strategy for income-generating real estate, profitability optimisation of rental operations, real estate advisory for ultra-high-net-worth individuals (UHNWIs) and institutional investors, and cross-border real estate investment. He provides data-driven, long-horizon advisory to investors in Japan and overseas.

Under the management philosophy "a company's most important asset is its people," he positions INA&Associates as a "people-investment company" and is committed to sustainable corporate-value creation through talent development. He also writes and speaks publicly on leadership and organisational culture in times of change.

He has passed eleven Japanese professional qualification examinations: Licensed Real Estate Broker (Takken), Certified Real Estate Consulting Master, Licensed Condominium Manager, Licensed Building Management Supervisor, Certified Rental Housing Management Professional, Gyōseishoshi Lawyer (administrative scrivener), Certified Personal Information Protection Officer, Class-A Fire Prevention Manager, Certified Auctioned Real Estate Specialist, Certified Condominium Maintenance Engineer, and Licensed Moneylending Operations Supervisor.

  • Licensed Real Estate Broker (Takken)
  • Certified Real Estate Consulting Master
  • Licensed Condominium Manager
  • Licensed Building Management Supervisor
  • Certified Rental Housing Management Professional
  • Gyōseishoshi Lawyer (Administrative Scrivener)
  • Certified Personal Information Protection Officer
  • Class-A Fire Prevention Manager
  • Certified Auctioned Real Estate Specialist
  • Certified Condominium Maintenance Engineer
  • Licensed Moneylending Operations Supervisor