Lately, the term "Wood Shock" (ウッドショック, uddo shokku) has been heard more and more often in Japan's housing industry.
Many people are not yet familiar with the term, so they may not know exactly what it refers to. This is a Japan-specific story worth understanding for anyone who owns, builds, or invests in housing in Japan: unlike in the United States or Canada, where homes are framed largely with domestically sourced lumber, Japan's wooden houses depend heavily on imported structural timber, so a disruption abroad is felt directly in Japanese construction prices.
So in this article we explain what Wood Shock is.
We look at how Wood Shock affects Japan's domestic housing industry, why it occurs, whether the container shortage is also a factor that aggravates it, and whether the problem can be solved with domestically produced timber.
If you want to deepen your knowledge of Wood Shock, please read on.
Wood Shock Has a Major Impact on Japan's Domestic Housing Industry
Wood Shock has a major impact on the domestic housing industry in Japan.
First, we explain what Wood Shock actually is and what kind of impact it has on the housing industry in Japan.
What Is Wood Shock in the First Place?
Wood Shock refers to a sharp rise in the price of imported lumber.
It was named after the oil shock (オイルショック, oiru shokku, the oil crisis of the 1970s) that occurred in the past.
Please remember it as a general term for the trade friction that stops imported lumber from coming into Japan.
The term Wood Shock has been heard often recently, so a growing number of people are curious about it.
However, Wood Shock has actually happened twice before.
The first Wood Shock had its origin in the tightening of forest-logging regulations in the United States from the 1990s onward, in order to protect owls that had become an endangered species.
Because forests could no longer be logged, a shortage in the supply of lumber occurred.
The second Wood Shock occurred just before the Lehman Shock (リーマンショック, riiman shokku, the global financial crisis) of 2008.
As the economy entered a boom, a rush of housing construction occurred and lumber prices rose.
That became the cause of the second Wood Shock.
The third Wood Shock, which is happening now, was triggered by the effects of the novel coronavirus.
It is also called the "third Wood Shock."
What Impact Does It Have on Japan's Domestic Housing Industry?
When Wood Shock occurs, it sharply raises the prices of Douglas fir (米松, beimatsu, the Japanese trade name for Pacific Northwest Douglas fir) and redwood glued laminated timber.
That in turn has a major impact on the housing market.
Douglas fir and redwood laminated timber are building materials often used in wooden houses.
They are frequently used for beams (梁, hari), the horizontal members that connect one post to another.
Because of their structural role, the lumber used for beams is ideally strong, or comes from old and thick trees.
However, few domestic Japanese timbers can meet those conditions, so the country is in a situation where it relies on imported lumber for most of its beam material.
Beams are an essential part of building a house, and without them a house cannot be built.
For that reason, builders must use imported lumber suited to beams even when its price is high.
If expensive imported lumber is used, the price of the house rises by that much.
In addition, there is a possibility that more small local builders (工務店, kōmuten) will find it hard to procure lumber because the costs do not add up.
Douglas fir and redwood laminated timber used for beams are often imported, but timbers used for posts, such as Japanese cypress (ヒノキ, hinoki) and Japanese cedar (杉, sugi), can also be procured easily from domestic sources.
Therefore, for timbers that are easy to obtain in Japan, such as cypress and cedar, the impact of Wood Shock is considered not so large.
Within the housing industry, house builders (ハウスメーカー, hausu mēkā, large national home-building companies) and local builders that handle low-cost housing often depend on relatively cheap imported lumber.
In such cases, the impact of Wood Shock becomes considerable.
By contrast, house builders and local builders that mainly use domestic lumber are considered less likely to be affected. For an investor from abroad, this is a useful screening question when judging the cost risk of a new-build project in Japan: ask which lumber the builder actually uses.
The impact of Wood Shock is also spreading to the furniture and interior industries, not just the housing industry.
It is unlikely that the prices of products now on store shelves will soar, but it is wise to assume that products to be manufactured and sold from now on are quite likely to be marked up.
Looking at it the other way around, for consumers, now is also a chance to buy furniture.
Why Wood Shock Occurs
The reasons Wood Shock occurs include the spread of pest damage in Europe and Canada, the growth in housing demand in the United States, and the very large effect of the grounding of a giant container ship in the Suez Canal.
Let us explain each reason in detail.
Pest Damage Is Spreading in Europe and Canada
In Europe, whitewood and other timbers have suffered damage from an insect called the spruce bark beetle (スプルースビートル, supurūsu bītoru).
As a result of that damage, the amount of lumber that can be supplied has become very small.
In Canada as well, forest damage caused by the pine beetle (マツクイムシ, matsukuimushi) has been spreading over the past several years.
Experts point out that the reason pine beetles increased in Canada is probably global warming.
Canada is a place where days of minus 30 degrees Celsius continue for more than a month in winter, so it was not an environment in which pine beetles could survive the winter.
However, the view is that warming has raised winter temperatures and allowed pine beetles to breed throughout the year.
Because pine beetles increased and forest damage spread, the supply of wood products has fallen by as much as 10 million cubic meters in a single year.
Because of that damage, 40 to 50 sawmill companies went bankrupt or closed within a few years.
Canada had been one of the largest lumber supply bases for the United States as well, but its shipments have fallen sharply and the situation is severe.
The fact that the United States has been increasing its imports from Europe is thought to be strongly influenced by the situation in Canada.
Housing Demand Is Growing in the United States
The growth in housing demand in the United States is also considered one of the causes of Wood Shock.
Because of the novel coronavirus, housing construction in the United States dropped temporarily in 2020.
However, after the lockdown was lifted in May 2020, demand for housing construction rose all at once.
From around July 2020 the movement became even more active, and the number of building permits for housing has continued to stay at a higher level than before.
One reason housing demand grew in the United States is that remote work was actively adopted.
As people spent more time at home through remote work, more of them bought new houses in the suburbs or renovated.
Fiscal spending and low-interest-rate policy are also thought to have spurred these actions.
It is also thought that even larger demand will arise in the second half of 2020.
The shortage of materials due to pest damage and wildfires, and sawmills having to close because of the novel coronavirus, combined with the growth in US housing demand, have upset the balance between demand and supply of the lumber used in construction.
Because supply cannot keep up with demand, the price of lumber inevitably soars.
That is also affecting Japan's housing industry.
The Container Shortage Is Also a Factor Accelerating Wood Shock
Wood Shock is also thought to be affected by the container shortage.
Here we explain how the container shortage is also a factor that accelerates Wood Shock.
What Caused the Container Shortage?
Several causes can be considered for why a container shortage arose.
The first reason is that the number of new containers manufactured fell.
This was already happening before the novel coronavirus appeared.
In 2019, the number of new containers manufactured was down 40% compared with the previous year.
Then in 2020, the spread of the novel coronavirus increased concerns about the outlook, and the operating rate of container factories declined steadily.
As a result, fewer containers were manufactured, and containers ran short.
The second reason is that cargo from Asia to North America increased sharply.
In China, the production of automobiles, machinery, electrical equipment and more has made a V-shaped recovery.
In step with that, stay-at-home demand rose in the United States, and imports of furniture, home appliances, toys and the like increased.
Under those circumstances, container cargo volumes at the ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach in the United States rose sharply.
That level exceeded the level of the previous year.
The third reason is that container-handling capacity has declined because of a shortage of port workers.
As coronavirus infections spread in the United States, the ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach fell into a shortage of port workers.
Containers pile up at the ports, and the ports are congested.
That pile-up and congestion also affected major ports around the world, and delays in sea transport and ships waiting offshore have become serious.
The fourth reason is that empty containers pile up in Europe and are not sent back to Asia.
In Europe, empty containers are piling up in warehouses and inland depots.
As a result, containers are not being returned to Asia, which becomes a cause that aggravates the container shortage.
Changes in Sea Freight and Air Freight Rates Also Have Wide-Ranging Effects
Changes in sea freight and air freight rates are also having wide-ranging effects.
Sea freight rates began to soar, citing a shortage of containers and space, from July 2020 on the westbound route to the United States, from September 2020 on the eastbound route to the United States, from October 2020 on the route to Europe, and from December 2020 for Korea and Japan.
Because of the spread of the novel coronavirus in Europe, container production was also stopped, although only in part.
As a result, the balance between exports and imports was upset.
Chinese companies use many spot contracts for shipping, so the European routes tend to be rising sharply.
On the other hand, Japanese companies often have long-term shipping contracts, so their prices have moved relatively steadily. This is another Japan-specific feature: long-term contracting is a common Japanese business practice, and it cushions Japanese importers against short-term spikes in a way that the spot-market approach does not.
As for air freight rates, the suspension of international passenger flights led to an increase in international cargo flights.
However, that does not mean that supply has expanded.
Because urgent transport and the decline in supply happened at about the same time, there were many cases of cargo shifting from sea freight to air freight.
As a result, air freight rates also soared, just as sea freight rates did.
What Effect Has It Had on Production and Logistics?
As the container shortage became serious because of the spread of the novel coronavirus, it has also had a major effect on production and logistics.
The effects of the novel coronavirus on international shipping include the following: reduced sea transport capacity due to city lockdowns, movement restrictions and shrinking production and sales; empty containers piling up in the United States; empty containers supplied from Europe to China and ASEAN not arriving in time; cargo being left behind in various parts of Asia; a serious shortage of empty containers and ship space in various parts of ASEAN; and a continuing chain of congested ships.
As for the effects on automobile shippers, factories in China and Japan were successively halted from late January 2020.
Around September 2020, production at factories in Japan and the United States gradually recovered, but the supply of parts to the US factories began to be delayed.
Spot transactions using airport transport and the ports on the US West Coast began to be carried out.
And that aggravated port congestion and created an unstable transport situation.
Because of the effects of the novel coronavirus, the ratio of logistics costs to sales of shippers in China has been rising steadily.
To resolve this, not only short-term responses but also medium- to long-term responses are essential.
Short-term responses include bringing the supply chain back to the home country, raising inventory levels, coordinating between distribution centers (DCs), and adjusting transport modes.
Medium- to long-term responses include adjusting production bases, diversifying the supply chain, and promoting logistics automation and visibility.
If production and logistics are heavily affected, it is natural to think that imports of materials needed for house construction, starting with lumber, will also be affected.
For that reason, knowing what effects are appearing in production and logistics is an important point.
Why Domestic Lumber Cannot Solve the Problem
If lumber prices are soaring for various reasons, some people may wonder whether the problem could be solved by using domestically produced lumber.
It is true that using domestic lumber would remove the need to depend on imports, and would prevent the disruption of imports caused by Wood Shock and the novel coronavirus.
However, there are reasons why this has not been done.
Let us now explain why domestic lumber cannot solve the problem.
1. Because Designs Assume the Strength of Imported Lumber
The first reason is that building designs assume the strength of imported lumber.
The building designs currently used by house builders and local builders in Japan often assume the strength of imported lumber.
For that reason, when switching to domestic lumber, the design has to be changed from the ground up.
When the design changes, the amount of lumber used also changes.
Therefore, even if a design is reworked around domestic lumber, it cannot be said for certain that it will become cheaper.
In some cases, the price using domestic materials may even turn out higher.
In that case customer demand may not be met, so the switch cannot be made easily. A comparable situation would be a builder in a country that frames houses to a fixed imported-timber grade standard: changing the species means redoing the structural calculations, not just changing the purchase order.
2. Because the Supply System Has Not Kept Up
The second reason is that the supply system has not kept up.
If imported lumber had been used, it cannot be ruled out that supply would fail to keep up if builders suddenly switched to domestic lumber.
The reason is that the number of workers in Japan has decreased, and the decline of forestry is marked.
Even if cedar and cypress used for posts can be supplied, larch (カラマツ, karamatsu) and similar timbers used for beams cannot be supplied immediately in volumes large enough to satisfy the market.
For that reason, building houses with domestic materials is considered difficult.
3. Because Planning Is Important in Forestry Production Systems
The third reason is that planning is important in the production system of forestry.
Trees do not grow immediately after being planted.
It takes more than 30 years before they reach the market.
If a wide area is felled, it cannot be restored to its original state quickly.
While trees are growing to a size that can be supplied to the market, builders rely on cheap lumber imported from overseas.
The workers in Japan's forestry are aging, and if no successors are found, the industry may fade away.
Forestry is an industry that sends products into the world over a long span of 30 to 50 years, so it is difficult for it to respond flexibly to phenomena such as Wood Shock.
Another concern is that, once Wood Shock settles down, domestic lumber will be at a price disadvantage compared with imported lumber.
4. Because There Is a Shortage of Lumber Dryers
The fourth reason is that there is a shortage of lumber dryers.
Lumber used in construction must be dried after it is sawn.
If drying is insufficient, the wood shrinks or deforms.
That would have a major effect on house building, so the shortage of dryers aggravates the shortage of domestic lumber.
There are two kinds of drying, natural drying and artificial (kiln) drying, but natural drying takes more than a year.
As for artificial drying, only as many dryers as match the conventional supply volume have been prepared.
For that reason, it is impossible to raise the supply volume immediately.
5. Because the Amount That Can Be Felled Is Fixed by Subsidy Arrangements
The fifth reason is that the amount that can be felled is determined in connection with subsidies.
Operators engaged in forestry to cut domestic lumber make use of subsidies.
Under those subsidies, the amount of lumber that can be felled is decided in advance, so the supply of domestic lumber cannot be increased all at once.
If an operator chooses to go without the subsidy in order to bring more domestic lumber to market, the operator would have to bear the loss.
Even though demand for domestic lumber is growing, the situation is that supply cannot be increased.
Wood Shock Makes the Challenges and Problems of Japan's Forestry Clear
Japan is a forest-rich country in which forests cover about 70% of the land.
According to "Top 10 OECD Member Countries by Forest Share, 2020" (OECD加盟国森林率上位10か国,2020), part of the main report of the Global Forest Resources Assessment 2020 (世界森林資源調査, Sekai Shinrin Shigen Chōsa), Japan ranks third in the share of land covered by forest, after Finland and Sweden.
Of the forests in Japan, roughly half are natural forests, roughly 40% are planted forests for producing lumber, and the remaining roughly 10% are bamboo groves and the like.
Japan's planted forests are mostly coniferous forests of cedar, cypress, and larch, which grow relatively fast and suit use as building material.
Many of the planted forests are now 30 to 50 years past planting and have reached the harvest season.
However, depopulation and aging are becoming serious in the villages whose residents have protected the forests until now.
As a result, there is a shortage of successors for those engaged in forestry.
Among them, forests whose owners are unknown are also increasing, and cases in which felling cannot be started even if people want to do it have become conspicuous.
On top of that, the price of cedar is not so high from the point of view of forestry producers.
At the current price the business does not pay, so maintaining the market price is also difficult.
In other words, it is considered extremely difficult to switch to a system of increased production while maintaining the market price.
From this we can see that even if early increases or switches to domestic lumber are urged, the likelihood of realizing them is quite low.
Some voices say that Wood Shock may be only temporary.
However, for Japan, which depends very heavily on imported materials, it is a major problem even if it is temporary.
This Wood Shock has brought to light how fragile Japan's industrial structure was.
For that reason, it has come to be thought that the supply chain needs to be rebuilt.
How Long Will Wood Shock Last? Are There Countermeasures?
Some people may feel anxious about how long Wood Shock will last.
There will also be people who want to know about countermeasures if any can be taken.
Next, we explain how long Wood Shock is thought to last, and what Wood Shock countermeasures local builders and home buyers can take.
How Long Is Wood Shock Thought to Last?
It is a situation in which it cannot be predicted how long Wood Shock will continue.
As mentioned above, the cause of Wood Shock is not just one.
There is no guarantee that these causes will be resolved at the same time, and it cannot be ruled out that new causes will arise.
For that reason, no one can predict how long Wood Shock will last.
Of course, it may be temporary.
However, as mentioned above, it has become clear that Japan's industrial structure is fragile, so it can be said that some kind of countermeasure must be taken.
Unless that is done, the country will go around in circles when it falls into a similar situation again.
What Wood Shock Countermeasures Should Local Builders Take?
It is thought that there are measures local builders can take to reduce the impact of Wood Shock even a little.
Let us look at which concrete measures are considered effective.
- Consult the Japan Finance Corporation about business funds
Because of Wood Shock, it is expected that many builders will struggle with cash flow to procure lumber.
To resolve worries about cash flow, we recommend consulting the Japan Finance Corporation (日本政策金融公庫, Nihon Seisaku Kin'yū Kōko, a government-owned lender that serves small and medium-sized businesses) about business funds.
The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism (国土交通省, Kokudo Kōtsūshō, MLIT) has notified industry groups as a whole to respond on matters of cash flow.
And the Japan Finance Corporation accepts consultations from local builders and others that are struggling with cash flow.
Even builders who have never borrowed from the Japan Finance Corporation, and builders whose business scale requires a construction business license, can consult it.
For that reason, cases of consulting the Japan Finance Corporation about business funds are increasing.
- Explain the situation to customers and prepare an agreement document
Under the conditions in which Wood Shock is occurring, it has become difficult to procure the lumber needed to build houses.
Explaining this to customers in advance and gaining their understanding is also an important point.
Specifically, the things to explain would include that it takes time to procure lumber, that lumber prices are likely to soar and exceed the budget, that the type of lumber may have to be changed, and that the construction period may be longer than planned.
In light of such situations, an agreement document needs to be prepared.
Agreement on changes to the lumber used, changes to the construction period, and the handling of claims for delay damages (遅延損害金, chien songaikin, a contractual penalty for late completion) arising from a change in the completion date is essential.
If agreement on the changes is not obtained, it may develop into trouble later.
If it develops into trouble, it will cause disadvantages for both the customer and the local builder, so explaining the situation to customers and preparing an agreement document can be called an important matter when concluding contracts under Wood Shock.
What Wood Shock Countermeasures Can Home Buyers Take?
The effects of Wood Shock also have a major impact on people who are about to buy a house, so they should not think it is unrelated to them, and should know whether there are measures they can take.
Let us now look at what Wood Shock countermeasures a home buyer can take.
- Ask a house builder or local builder that uses only domestic lumber
Among house builders and local builders, some use only domestic lumber.
If a company uses only domestic lumber, it can avoid being affected even if Wood Shock occurs.
If you are worried that construction costs will rise because of Wood Shock, please also consider the option of asking a house builder or local builder that uses only domestic lumber.
- Ask a house builder or local builder that is making corporate efforts
Even if imported lumber is used, by asking a house builder or local builder that is making corporate efforts, the impact may not become so large.
Such companies are likely to be able to build a wooden house at a price that is not much different from before Wood Shock.
Please check the websites of house builders and local builders, see what initiatives they are taking, and compare them.
- Choose a construction method other than wood
House construction methods are not limited to wood.
Wood Shock raises the price of lumber and so has a major impact on the price of wooden houses.
However, a steel-frame house uses lumber in fewer parts, so it can be said that it is not greatly affected by Wood Shock.
If you have no particular attachment to a wooden house, please build your own home while also considering other construction methods.
- Do not buy a house until Wood Shock settles down
If you are not in a situation where you must rebuild right away, you can also choose the option of not buying a house until Wood Shock settles down.
If you hold off buying, you need to judge at what point it would be possible to buy.
Check regularly how Wood Shock is developing and how lumber prices are moving, and reconsider buying at a time when you judge that the situation has calmed down.
Summary
Wood Shock, a term heard more and more often in the housing industry, is also having a major effect inside Japan.
Because Japan builds houses that rely on imported lumber rather than domestic lumber, a sharp rise in lumber prices directly affects house prices as well.
The main causes of Wood Shock are the spread of pest damage in Europe and Canada, and the growth in housing demand in the United States.
In addition, the container shortage is also thought to be a factor that accelerates Wood Shock.
In other words, it can be said that Wood Shock has a wide variety of causes, and it is hard to think that it will be solved easily.
To ease the situation even a little, it can be said that both the Wood Shock countermeasures that local builders should take and the countermeasures that home buyers can take need to be put into practice.
As countermeasures are taken, the situation may improve, making it possible to return to conventional methods and to increase domestic supply.
Also, even if a similar situation arises in the future, it is likely that Japan will be able to respond more smoothly than it can now.
If Japan becomes able to handle even unforeseen events, that would be ideal for Japan's forestry and housing industry, and an ideal result for customers as well.
