Skip to content
Real Estate Intelligence
COLUMN

What Are the Pros and Cons of Rental Housing? Compare with Homeownership to Choose the Right Home

This article explains the advantages of rental housing, such as no mortgage, flexibility, and no maintenance burden, as well as the drawbacks, including limited remodeling and retirement-related risk. It also compares renting and owning to help you choose a home that fits your life plan.

Last updated: About 1 min read

Should you own a home, or spend your entire life renting? Choosing where and how to live is a major life decision. Rental housing offers the freedom of living without the burden of a mortgage, but it also comes with the challenge of ongoing housing costs in retirement.

What are the advantages of rental housing?

The biggest advantage of rental housing is its flexibility in adapting to changes in your lifestyle.

No mortgage

Buying a home involves costs of tens of millions of yen and mortgage repayments that can last for decades. Renters pay monthly rent, but the psychological burden is very different because they do not carry a large debt obligation.

Lower upfront and maintenance costs

Upfront costs for rental housing include deposits, key money, and similar fees (and recently, cases where these are not required have been increasing), making them significantly less expensive than a down payment and other purchase-related costs for a home. In addition, there are no fixed asset taxes or major repair expenses.

The freedom to move at any time

You can easily change homes to match life changes such as a job transfer, career move, marriage, or divorce. If problems arise with neighbors, moving can also provide a practical solution.

What are the disadvantages of rental housing?

Renovation is not possible

Because the property is not owned by you, you cannot remodel the space to suit your preferences. One disadvantage is that it can be harder to create a living environment tailored to your comfort.

Rent continues even after retirement

With a homeowner-occupied property, housing costs generally drop significantly once the mortgage is paid off, but with rental housing, the same level of rent continues even after retirement. For that reason, any retirement asset plan needs to be designed with future rent payments in mind.

Which is right for you: owning or renting?

There is no single correct answer. The best choice depends on your life plan, income, family structure, and long-term outlook. Renting is often a better fit for people who relocate frequently or whose lifestyle is likely to change. Homeownership is often more suitable for those who prioritize a stable living environment over the long term.

Recommended reading

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q1. Which is cheaper overall: renting or owning a home?

In general, owning a home is often considered more advantageous over the long term once the mortgage has been fully repaid, but the answer also depends on repair costs, fixed asset taxes, and land price trends in the area where you live.

Q2. How can renters prepare for housing costs in retirement?

It is important to plan asset building and savings during your working years with future rent expenses in retirement in mind. Options such as real estate investment or savings-based financial products may also be worth considering.

Q3. Can you renovate a rental property?

In some cases, it may be possible if the work is DIY or uses removable fixtures, but as a rule, the property must be restored to its original condition. It is best to confirm this with the property management company or owner before moving in.

Q4. Does it become harder to rent as you get older?

Older tenants may sometimes be refused because of concerns such as the risk of dying alone. If you plan to live in rental housing for the long term, it is reassuring to keep senior-friendly rental housing and public housing among your options.

Daisuke Inazawa, President & CEO of INA&Associates Inc.

Author

President & CEOINA&Associates Inc.

President & CEO of INA&Associates Inc. Leads real estate brokerage, rental leasing, and property management across Greater Tokyo and the Kansai region. Specialises in income-property investment strategy and advisory for ultra-high-net-worth individuals.

Daisuke Inazawa is the President and CEO of INA&Associates Inc., a Japanese real estate firm headquartered in Osaka with a Tokyo branch. He leads the company's three core businesses — real estate sales brokerage, rental leasing, and property management — across the Greater Tokyo Area and the Kansai region.

His areas of expertise include investment strategy for income-generating real estate, profitability optimisation of rental operations, real estate advisory for ultra-high-net-worth individuals (UHNWIs) and institutional investors, and cross-border real estate investment. He provides data-driven, long-horizon advisory to investors in Japan and overseas.

Under the management philosophy "a company's most important asset is its people," he positions INA&Associates as a "people-investment company" and is committed to sustainable corporate-value creation through talent development. He also writes and speaks publicly on leadership and organisational culture in times of change.

He has passed eleven Japanese professional qualification examinations: Licensed Real Estate Broker (Takken), Certified Real Estate Consulting Master, Licensed Condominium Manager, Licensed Building Management Supervisor, Certified Rental Housing Management Professional, Gyōseishoshi Lawyer (administrative scrivener), Certified Personal Information Protection Officer, Class-A Fire Prevention Manager, Certified Auctioned Real Estate Specialist, Certified Condominium Maintenance Engineer, and Licensed Moneylending Operations Supervisor.

  • Licensed Real Estate Broker (Takken)
  • Certified Real Estate Consulting Master
  • Licensed Condominium Manager
  • Licensed Building Management Supervisor
  • Certified Rental Housing Management Professional
  • Gyōseishoshi Lawyer (Administrative Scrivener)
  • Certified Personal Information Protection Officer
  • Class-A Fire Prevention Manager
  • Certified Auctioned Real Estate Specialist
  • Certified Condominium Maintenance Engineer
  • Licensed Moneylending Operations Supervisor